Back to all essays
AI First

Claude vs ChatGPT for Founders: 6-Month Battle Test

·6 min read
George Pu

George Pu

Claude vs ChatGPT for Founders: 6-Month Battle Test

I've spent $1,200 testing Claude and ChatGPT for every business use case over 6 months. Built SimpleDirect features with both. Wrote marketing copy with both. Made strategic decisions with both.

The winner surprised me.

Here's exactly which AI to use for what, the true cost breakdown, and why most founders are using the wrong tool.

The Test Setup: Real Business Use Cases

Testing Period: 6 months (June-December 2024) Total Spend: $1,200 ($600 each) Use Cases Tested: 12 business categories Projects: SimpleDirect Desk development, ANC platform features, blog content, customer support

My Testing Framework:

  • Same prompts to both AIs
  • Real business problems (not toy examples)
  • Tracked time savings and quality
  • Measured actual business impact

Models Tested:

  • Claude: Sonnet 3.5, Opus (when available)
  • ChatGPT: GPT-4, GPT-4 Turbo, o1-preview

Here's what I learned.

Head-to-Head: 12 Business Use Cases

1. Strategic Business Planning

The Task: Analyze SimpleDirect's expansion into commercial lending

Claude's Response:

  • 2,800 words of structured analysis
  • Considered regulatory implications
  • Identified 5 specific risks with mitigation strategies
  • Provided implementation timeline with milestones
  • Quality: 9/10
  • Time: 15 minutes

ChatGPT's Response:

  • 1,200 words, more general advice
  • Missed key regulatory considerations
  • Generic expansion advice
  • Less structured approach
  • Quality: 6/10
  • Time: 10 minutes

Winner: Claude (by a lot) Why: Better at nuanced business analysis, considers second-order effects

2. Code Review and Technical Architecture

The Task: Review SimpleDirect's new payment processing architecture

Claude's Response:

  • Identified security vulnerability in API key handling
  • Suggested specific design pattern improvements
  • Provided refactored code examples
  • Considered scalability implications
  • Quality: 9/10

ChatGPT's Response:

  • Generic code review comments
  • Missed the security issue
  • Suggested popular but not contextually appropriate patterns
  • Less thorough analysis
  • Quality: 7/10

Winner: Claude Why: More thorough, better security awareness, contextual understanding

3. Marketing Copy and Content

The Task: Write landing page copy for SimpleDirect Desk

Claude's Response:

  • Compelling headline with specific benefit
  • Clear value proposition
  • Well-structured sections
  • Appropriate tone for B2B SaaS
  • Quality: 8/10

ChatGPT's Response:

  • Catchier headlines
  • More energetic tone
  • Better emotional appeal
  • Easier to read
  • Quality: 9/10

Winner: ChatGPT (slightly) Why: Better at persuasive copy, more engaging tone

4. Customer Support Responses

The Task: Handle complex technical support question about API integration

Claude's Response:

  • Step-by-step troubleshooting guide
  • Anticipated follow-up questions
  • Included relevant documentation links
  • Professional, helpful tone
  • Quality: 9/10

ChatGPT's Response:

  • Shorter, more direct response
  • Missed some edge cases
  • Good tone but less comprehensive
  • Faster to read
  • Quality: 7/10

Winner: Claude Why: More thorough, better anticipation of user needs

5. Financial Modeling and Analysis

The Task: Build revenue projections for ANC platform expansion

Claude's Response:

  • Built detailed Excel formulas
  • Considered multiple scenarios
  • Included sensitivity analysis
  • Explained assumptions clearly
  • Identified key metrics to track
  • Quality: 9/10

ChatGPT's Response:

  • Basic financial model
  • Single scenario planning
  • Missing important variables
  • Good explanations but less depth
  • Quality: 6/10

Winner: Claude (decisively) Why: Better at complex analytical tasks, more thorough modeling

The Task: Review terms of service updates for SimpleDirect

Claude's Response:

  • Identified 3 potential compliance issues
  • Suggested specific language changes
  • Explained legal implications
  • Recommended lawyer consultation for specific clauses
  • Quality: 8/10

ChatGPT's Response:

  • General feedback on clarity
  • Missed compliance issues
  • Suggested stylistic improvements
  • Less legal awareness
  • Quality: 5/10

Winner: Claude Why: Better legal reasoning, more risk-aware

7. Creative Brainstorming

The Task: Generate product feature ideas for SimpleDirect mobile app

Claude's Response:

  • 8 well-thought-out ideas
  • Considered user workflows
  • Included implementation complexity
  • Prioritized by business impact
  • Quality: 7/10

ChatGPT's Response:

  • 12 creative ideas
  • More outside-the-box thinking
  • Some impractical but inspiring
  • Better at connecting disparate concepts
  • Quality: 8/10

Winner: ChatGPT Why: More creative, better at ideation

8. Data Analysis and Insights

The Task: Analyze SimpleDirect's customer churn patterns

Claude's Response:

  • Systematic analysis framework
  • Identified 4 churn drivers
  • Suggested specific interventions
  • Recommended tracking metrics
  • Quality: 9/10

ChatGPT's Response:

  • High-level churn analysis
  • Generic retention strategies
  • Less specific recommendations
  • Missed some data patterns
  • Quality: 6/10

Winner: Claude Why: Better analytical depth, more actionable insights

9. Email and Communication

The Task: Draft investor update email

Want the full playbook?

I wrote a 350+ page book on building without VC. It's free to read online.

Read the free book

Claude's Response:

  • Professional structure
  • Appropriate level of detail
  • Balanced (wins and challenges)
  • Clear next steps
  • Quality: 8/10

ChatGPT's Response:

  • More engaging opening
  • Better storytelling
  • Slightly more persuasive
  • Easier flow
  • Quality: 8/10

Winner: Tie Why: Both excellent, different strengths

10. Research and Fact-Checking

The Task: Research Canadian fintech regulations for ANC expansion

Claude's Response:

  • Thorough regulatory overview
  • Specific compliance requirements
  • Recent updates included
  • Conservative, accurate approach
  • Quality: 9/10

ChatGPT's Response:

  • Good overview but less detailed
  • Some outdated information
  • More confident than warranted
  • Missed some nuances
  • Quality: 7/10

Winner: Claude Why: More accurate, better fact-checking, acknowledges limitations

11. Product Management Tasks

The Task: Prioritize SimpleDirect feature backlog

Claude's Response:

  • Systematic evaluation framework
  • Considered technical debt
  • Balanced user needs vs business goals
  • Detailed justification for each decision
  • Quality: 9/10

ChatGPT's Response:

  • Good prioritization logic
  • More aggressive on new features
  • Less consideration of technical factors
  • Easier to scan quickly
  • Quality: 7/10

Winner: Claude Why: More systematic, better product thinking

12. Crisis Management

The Task: Handle SimpleDirect API outage communication

Claude's Response:

  • Calm, professional tone
  • Clear incident timeline
  • Specific remediation steps
  • Proactive about prevention
  • Quality: 9/10

ChatGPT's Response:

  • Good crisis communication
  • More apologetic tone
  • Less technical detail
  • Faster to write
  • Quality: 7/10

Winner: Claude Why: Better crisis management instincts

The Scoreboard: Claude Wins 8-2-2

Claude Wins (8):

  • Strategic planning
  • Technical analysis
  • Customer support
  • Financial modeling
  • Legal review
  • Data analysis
  • Research
  • Product management
  • Crisis management

ChatGPT Wins (2):

  • Marketing copy
  • Creative brainstorming

Ties (2):

  • Email communication

Pattern Recognition:

  • Claude: Better at analytical, systematic, risk-aware tasks
  • ChatGPT: Better at creative, persuasive, energetic tasks

Cost Analysis: The Real Numbers

Subscription Costs (6 Months)

Claude Pro:

  • Cost: $20/month × 6 = $120
  • Usage: ~500 conversations/month
  • Cost per conversation: $0.24

ChatGPT Plus:

  • Cost: $20/month × 6 = $120
  • Usage: ~600 conversations/month
  • Cost per conversation: $0.20

API Costs (For Business Use)

Claude API:

  • Sonnet 3.5: $3 per million input tokens
  • Heavy usage: ~$50/month for business tasks
  • 6-month total: $300

ChatGPT API:

  • GPT-4: $10 per million input tokens
  • Same usage pattern: ~$120/month
  • 6-month total: $720

Total 6-Month Investment

Claude Total: $420 ($120 subscription + $300 API) ChatGPT Total: $840 ($120 subscription + $720 API)

Winner: Claude (50% cheaper for API usage)

Value Generated Analysis

Time Saved (Weekly):

  • Claude: ~8 hours/week (systematic tasks)
  • ChatGPT: ~6 hours/week (creative tasks)

At $200/hour billing rate:

  • Claude value: 8 × 26 weeks × $200 = $41,600
  • ChatGPT value: 6 × 26 weeks × $200 = $31,200

ROI Calculation:

  • Claude: $41,600 value / $420 cost = 99x ROI
  • ChatGPT: $31,200 value / $840 cost = 37x ROI

Winner: Claude (better ROI due to lower cost and higher value)

When to Use Which AI

Use Claude For:

✅ Business Analysis

  • Strategic planning
  • Financial modeling
  • Risk assessment
  • Competitive analysis

✅ Technical Tasks

  • Code review
  • Architecture decisions
  • Security analysis
  • Technical documentation

✅ Systematic Work

  • Process design
  • Legal review (preliminary)
  • Data analysis
  • Research tasks

✅ Customer-Facing Content

  • Support responses
  • Technical documentation
  • Professional communications

Use ChatGPT For:

✅ Creative Tasks

  • Marketing copy
  • Brainstorming sessions
  • Social media content
  • Blog post ideas

✅ Quick Tasks

  • Email drafts
  • Casual communication
  • Summary writing
  • General questions

✅ Persuasive Content

  • Sales copy
  • Pitch decks
  • Presentations
  • Proposal writing

The Hybrid Approach (What I Actually Do)

Primary: Claude Pro ($20/month)

  • 80% of business tasks
  • All analytical work
  • Technical decisions
  • Strategic planning

Secondary: ChatGPT Plus ($20/month)

  • Creative brainstorming
  • Marketing content
  • Quick questions
  • When Claude is down

Total Cost: $40/month for complete AI coverage

Want more essays like this?

Get my unfiltered thinking delivered to your inbox. Usually 2-3 per week.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

Real-World Implementation Strategy

For Solo Founders

If You Can Only Pick One:

  • Choose Claude if you're technical and analytical
  • Choose ChatGPT if you're creative and marketing-focused

Recommended: Start with Claude Pro, add ChatGPT later

For Small Teams (2-5 people)

Team Setup:

  • Founders: Claude Pro (strategic decisions)
  • Marketing: ChatGPT Plus (creative content)
  • Developers: Claude API (code assistance)

Budget: $60-100/month total

For Scaling Companies (5+ people)

Enterprise Approach:

  • Claude Teams for systematic work
  • ChatGPT Enterprise for creative teams
  • API access for both
  • Train team on which tool for what

Budget: $200-500/month depending on usage

Advanced Tips (After 6 Months)

Getting Better Results from Claude

Prompt Structure:

Context: [Your business situation]
Task: [Specific request]
Format: [How you want the response]
Constraints: [Limitations to consider]

Example: "Context: SaaS company with 500 customers, $50K MRR Task: Analyze churn data and recommend interventions Format: Structured analysis with specific action items Constraints: Limited engineering resources, 3-month timeline"

Getting Better Results from ChatGPT

Prompt Strategy:

  • Start with energy/enthusiasm
  • Ask for multiple options
  • Request creative angles
  • Use conversational tone

Example: "I need to write compelling landing page copy for our new feature. Give me 3 different approaches - one data-driven, one emotion-focused, and one benefit-heavy. Make them punchy and engaging!"

Quality Control Tips

For Both AIs:

  • Always fact-check important claims
  • Review financial calculations independently
  • Get human review for legal/compliance content
  • Test marketing copy with real users

The Verdict: Claude for Business, ChatGPT for Creativity

Winner: Claude (for business founders)

Why Claude Wins:

  • Better analytical reasoning
  • More systematic approach
  • Lower API costs
  • Better for technical tasks
  • More reliable fact-checking

When ChatGPT Is Better:

  • Creative content creation
  • Marketing copy
  • Brainstorming sessions
  • Casual communication

My Current Setup:

  • Primary: Claude Pro ($20/month) - 80% of usage
  • Secondary: ChatGPT Plus ($20/month) - 20% of usage
  • Total: $40/month for complete AI coverage

For Bootstrap Founders: If budget is tight, choose Claude. You'll get more business value per dollar.

The Future: Both are improving rapidly. Claude's lead in analytical tasks is growing. ChatGPT's creative edge remains strong.

Bottom Line: Claude is the better business AI. ChatGPT is the better creative AI. For founders building companies, Claude delivers more value.

Get Started:

  • Claude Pro - Best for systematic business tasks
  • ChatGPT Plus - Best for creative content
  • Start with one, add the other when budget allows